Stay at The Eagle Harbor Inn a Boutique Hotel on Bainbridge Island. Enjoy airy rooms, a garden courtyard, free parking, and easy access to Seattle attractions.
Guests appreciate the inn’s tranquil atmosphere, spacious and airy rooms, and convenient proximity to downtown shops and waterfront dining. The property offers a blend of modern amenities and a charming, homey feel, ideal for both relaxation and exploring the island.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
The Eagle Harbor Inn a Boutique Hotel offers a polished and inviting atmosphere with airy, homey rooms alongside modern townhouses. Guests benefit from a garden courtyard and complimentary parking, creating a comfortable and convenient stay. Rooms have been noted for their spaciousness, comfortable furnishings, and thoughtful amenities, including a coffee bar available around the clock in the small lobby area.
Located at 291 Madison Ave S on Bainbridge Island, the inn provides easy access to the island's downtown, which features charming shops, a variety of restaurants, and cultural attractions such as the Kids Discovery Museum and the local Museum of Art. Several guests have highlighted the quiet and private setting, as well as the walkability to nearby dining and waterfront spots, making it suitable for travelers seeking a relaxed island retreat without reliance on a car.
With a 4.6 rating based on 91 reviews, the property is regarded for its cleanliness, peaceful ambiance, and friendly service. Visitors appreciate the seamless self-check-in process and the owner's responsiveness to special needs or inquiries. While no on-site breakfast is offered, the location allows for easy access to nearby café options, including Pegasus Coffee directly across the street.
Situated within reach of Seattle’s notable attractions like the Space Needle and Museum of Pop Culture, the inn is also accessible from key airports such as Seattle-Tacoma International. This, combined with its LGBTQ+ friendly environment, makes the hotel well suited for visitors looking to explore the Seattle area while enjoying a quieter, more intimate lodging experience on Bainbridge Island.
The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
Peaceful and nice place to stay. The place was in order and furniture was comfortable. My entrance was through my garage and it had a private elevator. The elevator went to main floor and then top floor where will find two spacious bedrooms. There is 2 showers and a nice soaking tub. We had a beautiful view of the water and ferry. My favorite is that it was not stuffy. They do have hand saniter with the bathroom commodities. Thank you!
SO cute. Very private, quiet place. Clean room, very comfortable bed. Nice updated bathroom, free parking. Walking distance to everything downtown, great view from the room (Rockaway Beach). No on-site breakfast but several options within walking distance, and there was a coffee bar with snacks available all hours in the small lobby.
We had a great stay at the Eagle Harbor Inn. The Rockaway Beach Room felt airy and light-filled thanks to the vaulted ceiling. We appreciated that Sean was super responsive and accommodating when we had questions. And of course, the location across from Pegasus Coffee and right by all the great restaurants and shops on Winslow can’t be beat.
Top notch inn in a perfect location for a relaxing get-away on the island. Very convenient for all the amenities in town; once we parked, we really did not need our car again! ,The accommodations are peaceful and restful with a charming European feel. The host is very responsive to inquiries and the entire property is very clean and inviting.
The Eagle Harbor Inn was a great place during our stay on the island. Relaxing, clean, well built, and quiet. Our rental had a super easy parking spot to use and I appreciated the views we had from the building. Would stay here again.
We loved our stay at the Eagle Harbor Inn. The owner went the extra MILE to accommodate my “special-needs” We stayed in the Rockaway Beach Room. The room was spacious, with just enough decoration, but not overkill. The mattress, bedding and towels are deluxe! Ditto on the soaps and shampoos. We appreciated the off street parking. The location is “spitting distance” from the waterfront marina, view restaurants and waterfront stroll. It’s also just one block from the west side of the downtown commercial district. In other words, just park your car at the hotel and go! We will return!
Very nice place to stay. Rooms are great, location is perfect.
We stayed for a long weekend at Eagle Harbor Inn. Our room was comfortable, spacious, and a small fridge. Check in was seamless, no front desk, you get a code to get in the small lobby area and to your room. The lobby has brochures and information about local attractions, drink glasses, wine glasses, and coffee cups. They provide coffee and tea every morning in the lobby. The Inn is within easy walking distance to many shops and restaurants. We highly recommend Eagle Harbor Inn. Thanks so much for your hospitality.
Island hamlet with the Kids Discovery Museum & Museum of Art, plus charming stores & global eats.
Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in Washington. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.
56,991 reviews 400 Broad St, Seattle, WA 98109, United States
19,064 reviews 325 5th Ave N, Seattle, WA 98109, United States
24,091 reviews 305 Harrison St, Seattle, WA 98109, United States
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Stay at Aloft Waukee with free WiFi, indoor pool, petfriendly rooms, and fitness center. Close to Des Moines International Airpo...
Relax at Hampton Inn & Suites Chicago/Aurora featuring free WiFi, indoor pool, fitness center, and free parking near Interstate 8...
Enjoy a 4.5star stay at Old Victory Hotel, Maybell, CO. Kidfriendly amenities, close to Maybell Park and 58 mins from Yampa Vall...
Stay at STONE`S MOTEL in Dale, IN offering an outdoor pool, free WiFi, and petfriendly rooms. Close to Interstate 64 and top att...
Stay at Comfort Suites Grayslake near Libertyville North, a 4.3star hotel offering free WiFi, hot breakfast, indoor pool, and gy...
Stay at Harvest Inn in Ellendale, ND. Enjoy free WiFi, parking, air conditioning, and kidfriendly amenities near Pheasant Lake a...
3.7star extended stay hotel with free WiFi, gym, outdoor pool, and kitchens in some rooms. Near I77, Carowinds, and Charlotte D...
Contemporary allsuite hotel in Phoenix offering free breakfast, indoor pool, petfriendly rooms, and close to Phoenix Art Museum ...
Experience upscale suites, spa, and wine bar at Rancho Valencia Resort & Spa in Rancho Santa Fe. Near Torrey Pines Reserve and Del...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
